It may not be the hardware; it may be the the OS. Since upgrading to Sierra, I've been plagued by various runaway kernel processes randomly eating 100% of the CPU. Have finally managed to kill most of them through deleting .plists and the like -- all for native MacOS apps like Contacts by the way, not in any 3rd-party apps -- but this kind of bugginess could easily produce the kind of results that Consumer Reports saw.