Ask HN: Why aren't there 3rd party laptop power adapters? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Why aren't there 3rd party laptop power adapters?

2 pointsbrightball6 comments

Aside from mag-safe adapters for the likes of Apple laptops, I'm just wondering why there aren't 3rd party power adapters available. Clearly, Apple put some time into designing the form factor of theirs but other companies don't seem to invest nearly the same effort. Since it's just a power supply, this seems like an area where a 3rd party could provide "one power supply to rule them all" with form factor, built in surge protection and adapters to fit various laptops.

Just wondering how, in 2016, power supplies are so bad?

View on HN

Actually there are plenty! Search for 'multi laptop charger' or 'universal' or keywords that imply interchangeability. Like this randomly picked unit [1], they typically come with a voltage selector and a variety of plugs that can be switched out to fit a particular socket.

Potential problems with these devices are manyfold. They won't be specialized to deliver a particular amperage [2]; the voltage selector means additional moving parts that can fail, and mainstream brands usually don't play in this space, so the quality can run the gamut from decent to sketchy to hazardous.

[1] http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=9SIA6RP37N67... [2] http://lifehacker.com/pay-attention-to-charger-amperage-to-j...

This one looks along the lines of what I was thinking. Thanks!

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=9SIA8UY3HB59...

There's no demand really. Would you pay premium for an extra power supply? I wouldn't.

I would, however, pay premium for a power supply that doesn't fall apart like the Apple chargers do. (That being said, I consider the price Apple charges for their adapters premium as it is).

I'd pay a premium for a quality power supply that was lighter, smaller & cleaner. Bonus for a retractable cord.

Sounds like you guys have a good business idea

Reply on news.ycombinator.com