Zencoder (YC W10) Wants To Be The AWS Of Video Encoding
techcrunch.com
techcrunch.com
For http://OneFrameOfFame.com I was looking for a video encoding service that would take a bunch of images & sound file as input, and would encode it to a video file. Since none of the cloud video encoding parties I looked at (Encoding.com, Heywatch, ankoder) offered this, I ended up renting a linode VPS and encoding myself with ffmpeg. Which turned out to be not that hard. If you need the management tools, there are packages like http://pandastream.org/
Speaking as a company that reluctantly made a decision to offer this for our customers when we couldn't find (a few years ago) an affordable volume solution to outsource, I agree with you completely.
Given the rate of change and state of tools, running even an in-house encoding solution is likely to be a much bigger undertaking than expected.
In-house IT staff would need to understand distributed computing, dynamic load based provisioning, web services software development, and somehow, blended with that, the black art of producing good looking video at low bitrates using minimal CPU time. Any one of these areas is a full discipline on its own.
If I understand correctly, Posterous got funding, and is pushing this part out the door to Zencoder. That's a smart decision. Focus on what you do.
The video industry needs more Zencoders and fewer people trying to do it in house. There are still far more backlogs of unencoded video than there are movies online.
Our flat rate transcoding pricing (http://www.advection.net/pricing/transcoding-pricing) is based on the idea of an encoding queue with bursting. Under the hood, it's a similar cloud approach, but more economical for those with volumes or steady encoding work. Customers--or their end users--can upload at any rate (volumes of upload sessions at once through gateways located around the country for low latency), or ship drives. The queues process at a steady predictable rate, delivering content directly to the network.
In the course of processing countless libraries for clients, we've found they tend to have such unique ideas about the end result that a "one size fits all" web service often doesn't meet their needs out of the box.
So, we also offer Windows Media (WMV), Silverlight (VC-1), Ogg Theora, and cross-player H.264 encoding, adaptive bitrate encoding for Apple devices, iPhone video rotation, automatic thumbnails, web postbacks so you don't have to poll, incoming files of up to 4.7GB in size, and arbitrarily complex encoding requirements.
To your point about images + sound, for example, some clients supply metadata as XML, and using the metadata we generate pre-roll and post-roll video footage that stitches onto the transcoded video.
(We also have a consumer service that bundles both encoding and storage into a single "per minute" price. Consumers shouldn't need to know about gigabytes.)
I know they have their reasons, and I respect them, but I do think it is a mistake and a limitation.
I was thinking they were targeting film and media agencies (high-end market); instead of the thousands little bootstrapping startups.
zencoder should look into colocating servers and having customized servers with a video card capable of video transcoding... their costs would lower dramatically
Probably not Zencoder's premier market though...
Input: just about everything
Output: H.264 video, AAC audio, and MP3 audio, in a MP4 or Flash 9+ container format. Ogg/vorbis/theora are coming soon, as are a few others that we can't talk about yet. We've decided to take the "narrow" approach for now - 99% of the demand that we see is for these five codecs (H.264, AAC, MP3, Theora, Vorbis). If there's anything in particular that you're looking for, let us know.
"... a few others that we can't talk about yet."
With the On2/Google link this sounds like VP8.Oh, and then a harder one: Could you take a bunch of images & soundtrack file, and render it to a movie?
Not at the moment. It's something we're considering at some point, though.
As for the last question: when you're offered a spot in YC, you don't turn it down!