I think we may have disabled it.
You also might just actually need a beefier server. But at the very least you should be able to serve the homepage, which doesn't change super often, to everyone.
Congrats on having a site popular enough that you get to learn about a whole new world of tools and technologies!
If that does not work, will have to look into server options.
Thank you for your help and encouragement! :-)
The next best thing is making sure APC is set up on your server. I've also had success tuning settings in Apache to help with memory use, but that's a lot more time consuming.