Hacker News Reader

A bank robbery still has about as much in common with copyright violation as with pirating actual ships. I am not threatening anyone when committing copyright violations

A much more convincing argument could be made that theft and copyright violations are the same. Buy theft has quite low punishments (at least in California).

View on HN

Unauthorized use or reproduction is not theft, as it does not deprive or interfere with use of the original copy.

Stealing your furniture is theft. Taking a look at your furniture, and carving another set exactly like it is copyright infringement.

..if that argument were not destroyed by the Supreme Court many years ago. Infringement is not theft, no matter how much big businesses want to equivocate the two in people's minds.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com