Ask HN: is it safe to have ".net" in a product name (considering MS's .NET)? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: is it safe to have ".net" in a product name (considering MS's .NET)?

7 pointsmojuba6 comments

This is going to be a commercial product, something like "Orange.net" as an example, and I'm thinking about acquiring the corresponding domain name. It's going to be a web-based application, both hosted and for intranet use.

My main concern is a possible clash with Microsoft's .NET and their family of products that end with ".NET". How safe is it to have a name/trademark that ends with, say, lowercase ".net"?

Ours is a UNIX-based product and has nothing to do with Windows/.NET technologies anyway. The first part of the name won't clash with any other trademark in the software industry.

Thank you for your answers.

View on HN

There are several applications with ".NET" in the name.. Many of them seem to use the this moniker because they are built using .NET.. (duh)

http://www.microsoft.com/about/legal/en/us/IntellectualPrope... seems to give some advice on this topic for .NET framework related apps.

But, as far as I can tell, "(.Net logo)" is their only registered trademark concerning .NET. you can see a list of their trademarks here: http://www.microsoft.com/About/Legal/EN/US/IntellectualPrope...

I'd consult with a lawyer first, but I think you're good to go. There are many apps and websites that have ".net" in their name, and the .net domain predates Microsoft's framework by quite a bit.

Thanks, that clears the question up a bit.

It would be interesting to find out if those apps and services existed before MS came out with .NET. Obviously pre-existing ones are a lot safer in this regard.

I just thought that Microsoft has essentially hijacked the dot-net syllable, even though it belongs to everyone in principle, and even if it's safe to use in trademarks. Their .NET products are now so ubiquitous and well promoted that a computer/network product with .net in the name would very likely be associated with Microsoft in users' minds when they first see or hear about it.

I agree with you somewhat. There seems to be a divide between the cases of the text. Since Microsoft's framework is named in all upper-case.. it seems to be the convention for .NET framework related apps/companies. If a company was named "Orange.net," I wouldn't think they were related to MS or .NET.

There are a lot of companies and products that use this name... I'm sure you've researched it a bit, I can think of about 5 off the top of my head. My guess is as long as you aren't a threat to Microsoft's income.. you'll be just fine.

You really need a trademark lawyer to do a search and review of that name. Don't trick yourself into thinking you'll be okay without getting a qualified opinion. I'm sure MS has tons of filed trademarks, and until you get a trained person to review specifically what MS and others have trademarked, how their claims are worded, how broadly their mark can be applied, etc. I went through this process with a trademark lawyer, and came away knowing a lot more than when I went into it. If this product/company is worth anything to you, then spend a couple thousand and get the name cleared and in the process you'll also learn a lot for future projects.

Ask a trademark lawyer of course, but given the existence of .net as a domain I'd guess you're relatively safe. The only problem I can foresee is if your application were a software development tool, then it would be hard to argue you weren't referencing MS.

Contact the creators of Paint.Net and ask them how they've fared. Their site is here:

http://www.getpaint.net/

Reply on news.ycombinator.com