Impossible Coin in Super Mario 64 | Hacker News Reader

Impossible Coin in Super Mario 64

youtube.com

187 pointshighwind24 comments

The exploration and reasoning here is like a detailed report on a science experiment. I liked the layout of the presentation from noticing an incongruity to explaining exactly what was happening. Then the video surprised me by putting forth a hypothesis on why the 'world' was the way it was.

It has benefits over real-world experimentation because the fundamentals of the system are known and everything can be observed. No messy approximations are needed. Most guesses can be confirmed. But then we still end up with an unconfirmed hypothesis about how the situation came up in the first place. Reasoning is presented but there's no way to confirm it beyond asking...the creators.

The tooling used to recreate certain game situations is like a magical testing apparatus that doesn't really exist in the real world.

I respect the amount of effort and time that goes into videos like these. It's the best part of internet.

Check out the SM64 parallel universes video if you really wanna get your mind blown.

Yeah, most of the detailed explanations are on his main channel: https://www.youtube.com/user/pannenkoek2012/videos

Discovering how to gain enough speed to clip into modulo copies of the level is one thing, but extending that and finding surfaces that can deflect you in useful directions is a totally different level of commitment. (Also I'm curious how he managed to create the relative view--did he hack the ROM to fix that? I'm sure he mentions it somewhere.)

seconded

Video in question: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kpk2tdsPh0A

Wow, that was amazing! And the complex combination of tricks and glitches, along with the math to understand them, was very artfully done!

It's basically debugging, but without the source code. And some arcane bug the designers didn't care to fix decades ago :-).

or didn't know of

Didn't even have to click the link to know it was Pannen. The guy truly embodies the concept of Virtual Exploration.

If you haven't done so already, go ahead and watch his Watch For Rolling Rocks .5 A Press commentary.

If you like this, you would probably appreciate

https://www.reddit.com/r/videogamescience/

And

https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMakingOfGames/

Awh I wish he'd shown a hacked implementation of slope X and how the bowling balls would have rolled the other way :)

I love these types of videos that dive into the nitty-gritty of how certain games work. I wish the author would have explained more why there is no position that the coin spawner works correctly in. Are they saying that while playing the game there's no way to move it, or that even if the coin spawner were placed correctly (on the ground) it would still not work?

No, the video is saying that if the coin spawner were in the usual location (above ground) it would work fine. It postulates that this was an oversight: at one point the ground was raised (to provide a ramp for the bowling balls) and they forgot to raise the spawner with it.

Both were stated in the video. seems contradicting:

- https://youtu.be/iPILIf7ru48?t=4m4s

- https://youtu.be/iPILIf7ru48?t=8m11s

No, it's saying there's no mechanism (aside from directly modifying the game code) with which to move the spawner into a position that works. It's not saying that no such position exists.

I took it to mean that however he is hacking the game doesn't support moving coin spawners. That part honestly confused me too.

He's certainly capable of hacking the game to move the coin spawner via third-party tools; what the video is demonstrating is that there's no way to move the spawner while in-game using only button inputs on the control pad.

Shouldn't that be obvious? Or is this like those crazy hacks where they glitch the game with extreme controller input and cause it to branch immediately to the end screen?

IIRC some of his other videos show how you can duplicate and move objects around in-game.

I'd like to see a video of someone playing a modified version of this level, with the original slope restored.

This is some fine digital archaeology.

I love development postmortems of games from my childhood.

I know it's a little late but I'n entitled to a refund. or Nintendo should release a patch. lol

Reply on news.ycombinator.com