Hacker News Reader

Comment by ramtatatam | Hacker News Reader

It will be interesting to see consequences of referendum once BREXIT actually happened (the procedure is not yet started).

In my opinion UK will get similar deal to Switzerland. I would not base my forecasts on short term fluctuations in GBP or in assumptions that migration will decrease. Both will depend on actual deal UK will get with EU and I'm quite sure this deal will be a win-win for both. Because both EU and UK will get better by continuing to trade together than not to. UK is a major consumer for EU market and this won't change - and it's in EU best interest to make sure this won't change.

View on HN

It took Switzerland decades to get all those trade deals and bilateral agreements. Without the need to negotiate lots and lots of agreements with other countries at the same time.

The UK will wake up very soon, very hard to a bleak reality.

Perhaps I'm wrong but I get the impression that most 'remainers' very much hope this will be the case.

I think it's likely that much of what is said right now is posturing for the domestic populations. However I don't think it's in EU political interest to offer the UK a good deal.

I fear we will end up worse off overall but what I particularly want to know about is how it will effect dev...

Why do you think it's not in EU's best interest to trade with UK? UK is over 65mln country, great market - certainly not the one you would want to get isolated from.

It is in their interest; however the political integrity of the EU is more in their interest and the two are at odds with each other. Further, it isn't about isolation, rather the nature of the deal. The UK must trade with the EU at least in part because the current account deficit implies that we provide value add services: the initial value of which needs to be imported.

We leave in such interesting times :-) We will observe very future of this political project. It evolved a lot since it's beginnings, I can't wait to see what will it evolve to.

The EU is many countires, only a few of them have any significant exports to the UK but they all have to agree.

It's not so much whether to trade but on what terms, in what goods, whether there is a customs barrier and whether EU rules conflict with other deals.

E.g. when we're out of the CFP, will Spain block imports of UK seafood in retaliation? If we subsided e.g. steel, would that be subject to anti dumping tariffs?

There's an almost infinite amount of detail in which we could lose out.

I would not make such predictions - there is always 'what-if' game we can play. 'what-if' UK gets trading boost with Australia? ;-) Lets stay positive and make sure we grow our businesses (as usual).

I'm not sure what would make UK not to get such agreements especially if both EU and UK are interested in getting them. What politicians are saying is a bit off from actual business and it's in everybody's business to keep trading and making money :-)

Anything other than that - I would rather prefer not to make bold statements that `UK will wake up` etc. until I actually see the deal (ignoring all white noise produced by politicians and media).

A deal like Switzerland? Really?

Because Switzerland has to let EU citizens in to live and work there. Not quite as freely as if they were Schengen members, but still.

The whole point of immigration was not that immigration itself is wrong but that decision weather and who to let in was made outside UK. As you can see Switzerland has got fairly nice model where they attract highly skilled workforce and there is nothing wrong about trying to get the same model in UK. And I'm really cheering Brits to get there. Knowing their pragmatism they will.

... unfortunately the labour pyramid is such that the unskilled workers are required in much larger numbers than the skilled workers. If they are not imported then the wages would need to go up very substantially before those from the UK would be willing to wait tables, flip burgers, etc. Labour cost inflation from bottom up kills margin.

This isn't true though. Both countries are currently part of free movement arrangements: that is, anyone with an EU passport must be let in and allowed to work as if they were a local.

Swiss have also voted to change this and also haven't worked out how. http://openeurope.org.uk/today/blog/swiss-eu-compromise-free...

Switzerland is in Schengen. And free movement of labor isn't covered by Schengen.

Indeed, but the whole purpose of Brexit was to decrease migration. It's a publicly stated red-line for the negotiating team. Further, there is no way to say whether the fluctuation in GBP is short term ... The new world may turn the UK into a net exporter, in which case the GBP may stay lower for much longer.

As far as I remember this point of pro-leave campaign was quite misunderstood by media. My understanding always was that UK does not want to be told who to accept and how many. UK is very much interested in migration, just they would favor skilled and highly educated people (like Switzerland do). Actually funny thing is that there is a lot of immigration to UK from outside of EU :-) And I would not expect that will change because of Brexit...

I think it likely will because GBP as an export currency has lost almost 20%. It's just not as interesting a deal. Unless wages are forced up to attract foreign pros which ends up being a further hit to business.

Yeah, I'm tracking GBP closely and it's hitting levels from 2.5-3 years ago (though still far from 6-years minimum). Current short-term trend is even bullish :-) Fingers crossed all those bad forecasts are not based on facts :-)

I'm interested in what you're looking at which says that. Against the dollar 2.5-3 years ago GBP was never below 1.47, since the referendum, the highest it has been is 1.34 and that was the lowest we got in the 2008/2009 crash.

Ah sorry, I should have mentioned I was tracking GBP against PLN (much much less known currency ;-) )

Against EUR it is not doing THAT bad (but still BAD), but we were over 1.30 in GBPEUR and now we're 1.12 (and hit lows of 1.10 and even 1.09).

For me that causes a problem as I'm saving for a house in the continent, which I have to pay in EUR, now that I might have to leave the UK as my status is not guaranteed: https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2016-10-19/debates/F13...

Switzerland's model is exactly what the UK has now: EU citizens are allowed to work in Switzerland. Switzerland isn't allowed to make special restrictions on some groups of people.

They want to because they had a referendum on it and it's legally binding to them, but the EU has told them that that means losing free market access (e.g., https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/jul/03/eu-swiss-singl... ).

I'm afraid it's not. As far as I'm aware Switzerland cannot be told by EU to accept whatever number of immigrants from any place in the world. Swiss benefits model is substantially different than any other European country and I can't imagine any non-skilled immigrant would try to get to Switzerland to exploit it..

Apart from that tabloids will make a lot of noise around this, obviously it's great topic to get some news :-) In this uncertain time it is not that easy to make predictions, especially when it comes to such high level.

Same as the UK.

Both the UK and Switzerland have to allow people from the EU to travel into and work in their country, don't need to provide them with benefits if they don't have a job. In return UK and Swiss citizens have the same rights in the rest of the EU.

Both the UK and Switzerland can decide to allow people from outside the EU in whatever way they want.

In 2015 during the migrant crisis EU governments decided to relocate 160,000 refugees over Europe, but the UK opted out ( http://www.express.co.uk/news/world/607349/Migrant-crisis-ma... ) so this doesn't apply to them.

I don't agree, it's not same as the UK - talking from experience. Swiss citizens do not have to allow people from EU to travel and work, the amount of formalities you have to pass is much more than if you was moving to UK.

When was that? In theory the rules for EU citizens are exactly the same ( https://www.sem.admin.ch/sem/en/home/themen/fza_schweiz-eu-e... ) but in practice implementation may differ, I guess. Did you have a job there before moving?

A few years ago I was applying for a job in there. Did not get it in the end but got close enough to start discovering ins and outs of their system - UK is a heaven compared to Switzerland :-)

The UK already has full control of non-EU immigration and stringent criteria. Are you getting immigration, asylum, and the Dublin convention n refugees mixed up?

They already have the win-win deal. That's what they're exiting.

It seems more than 50% of Britons (who bothered to go and vote) do not think same way as you do.. Otherwise if they had such a great deal with the EU why would they vote to leave?

I believe it's their right to revise whatever agreement they had with EU and each other country is more than welcome to do the same. It's what happens when you are trading, every now and then people want to renegotiate their terms and there is nothing wrong about it.

They have been led to believe they can have some kind of fantasy deal that would be even better for them (no payments to Europe so the NHS can get more, control over immigration, but all the pros of the EU unchanged), but forget completely that that would not be "win-win" from the viewpoint of the EU and thus won't happen.

They're not revising their agreement, they're kicking it out entirely (work that took decades) and want to re-start on their own terms.

People can make choices and there's nothing "wrong" about that, but some choices are smarter and less damaging for everyone involved than others.

We shall see :-) Making statements about the future in this uncertain time is somewhat loaded with great error. And I believe it will be for good to Britons. Cheer up :-)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com