Should have, yes, if you really felt that way. And if you can feel that way geniunely, that's the best.
However, I don't think it's right to lie like that if you don't really feel that way. You can go a long way being nice without lying.
But, on don't just give up and say, "I'm just not nice." That's a problem, and if you feel that way all the time, you should go see or talk to someone: a family member, a friend, a GP doctor, a psychiatrist, or anyone that will listen and help you figure out the real problem. You might need more sleep. You might need medicine. You might need a chiropractic adjustment. You might need to vent. You might need to just spend time with another person. You might need to be alone in nature.