Hacker News Reader

Comment by curt15 | Hacker News Reader

Unless they pledge iphone-class software support, I can't think of any announcements that would really move Android forward.

View on HN

I think he means providing software support, like updates. It is unacceptable for a $650 phone to only get 2 years worth of updates. Apple provides 4-5y. Sure, sometimes features are removed on older devices, and they run slower, but surely that's better than no updates at all. My company will not allow phones to connect to the exchange server if you have a phone that doesn't get monthly security updates.

This exactly, and I'm referring especially to security patches. Nexus devices are the best among Android but still pale in comparison to iOS. Google Play Services can't patch vulnerabilities in the core system libraries or the kernel. A smartphone without software updates is like a desktop computer without access to Windows updates. If Google wants enterprises to take Android more seriously, it needs a flagship line of devices with enterprise-grade software support.

I have a Nexus 5X on Project Fi and my phone gets updates very frequently. I have updates at least every month if not every couple of weeks.

What I'm taking away from this is that you have never had a Nexus device, or even used one.

* The Nexus devices (during lifetime, usually 1 year less than iPhones) are patched sooner and more often than iOS.

* Google Play Services shouldn't be able to patch system libraries or the kernel, that would be a security issue. Patching those is what a system update is for.

* Nexus devices have (IMO) much better "enterprise-grade" software support than iOS, whatever that means. And it's only set to be better with N. [1]

[1] http://www.techrepublic.com/article/three-important-security...

The oldest phone to get iOS 10: iPhone 5, released Sep 2012.

The oldest phone to officially get Android 7: Nexus 5, released in Oct 2013.

Sure, it's 1 year less, but you sure did exaggerate. Also Nexus phones get more frequent updates than iPhones, and I'd argue they're much better updates.

The Nexus 5 isn't getting Android 7.

Oh, I guess I was wrong, I was basing it on this. [1]

[1] https://android.googlesource.com/device/lge/hammerhead/+/and...

Wait, are you saying that the Nexus phones have had anything but better software support than iPhones?

Are you saying they have not?

What are we all saying?!

Are you saying we have not said?

Is there anything that hasn't been said yet?

So you're saying there's a chance!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com