Three Sheldons
buzzfeed.com
buzzfeed.com
Why should we delude ourselves that he is genuinely remorseful or that he will redeem himself for such a horrific crime? Some criminals reform, others don't. It is a mistake to assume that everyone can or will mend their ways. One consequence of the article's theme, the fact that we don't fully control our destiny (absence of free will) is that the likelihood of recidivism is high.
Even if we accept that not everyone can reform, what should we do about it? It is similar to the problem of sending innocent men to prison. I would err on the side of caution and freedom.
Kudos to the author for the excellent writing, and to the Sheldons for sharing their story. Speaking as a white man who grew up 8 blocks from the apartment mentioned in the article, it's both surreal and saddening to learn how drastically different (meaning unfair) their lives were and continue to be.
Edit: help if I include the name: "All God's Children", by Fox Butterfield
In this article for example, the Sheldon family story was told in great detail, but Yu, a university student who was killed while walking down the street, for no fault of his own, barely got a paragraph or two. I wonder how many of those arguing for more lenient sentencing laws would change their minds, if they were exposed in detail to all the lives that were ruined or ended by the actions of criminals.