Hacker News Reader

Comment by Jerry2 | Hacker News Reader

>Granted, I use zsh, but I think it works pretty much the same in bash.

I also use zsh and I don't even use ctrl+r anymore. I just type a portion of the command I remember and hit the up arrow key. Almost always the command I want is only one to three arrow keys away. zsh matches partial commands really well.

View on HN

Bash has similar commands available to move up and down by matching commands. However, I find such modal behavior of up/down confusing; I prefer to have up and down always move by one command, and use C-r for reverse isearch.

Agreed, but this only works if you know you are right about the beginning of the command. Ctrl-R is still the best way I know to search for a command that I may not be sure about the first letters of.

I like the incremental searching that using control-r lets you do. That can come in really handy when I don't remember precisely what the command I want is.

I can start typing and then type more once I see some results to hone in more precisely to what I want, or even backspace over some of what I've typed and type some more without having to start all over again.

Also, using control-r instead of the arrow keys doesn't force me to move my wrists and lets me keep my fingers mostly on the home row. I try to use the arrow keys as little as possible.

Not moving your hand away from the home row is a good point!

Now I gotta retrain my muscle memory :)

You should be able to use ctrl-p/n for arrow up/down. That keeps your hand on the homerow. Forget about arrow keys (especially on a typical mac keyboard).

Ctrl-p/n are a quicker way to go up and down the history.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com