Ask HN: How do you evaluate a recruiter?
What are your positives/negatives?
What are your positives/negatives?
1st - Check out their profile-- do they look real? Does their firm online presence look legit?
2nd - What's the tonality of the email exchange? Is this someone with solid business acumen or a flunky?
3rd- Have a script ready-- "Joe, thanks for reaching out. You may appreciate, I get several requests like yours every week. So we don't waste too many cycles, please forward a full, detailed position summary. Also, tell me about your relationship with the client/hiring executive. If it's not a match for me, happy to see if I can refer some one."
That dialog should inform if it's worth going forward.
Like all salesmen, recruiters prefer to have live conversations to foster discovery and build rapport. A 10 minute exploratory phone conversation will tell you a lot.