Hacker News Reader

Comment by jpalomaki | Hacker News Reader

+1 for this. The null conditional is also pretty nice thing for the chained method calls. In C# you can write like this:

  int? count = customers?[0]?.Orders?.Count();

https://msdn.microsoft.com/fi-fi/library/dn986595.aspx

Pragmatic features like this are one reason why I love C#. I get the feeling that language designers are actually looking at real world code and thinking what kind of features would be it better.

View on HN

Slight aside: please don't abuse the Elvis operator like that (by using it on every single nullable reference), it could easily grow into a widespread anti-pattern that makes debugging harder.

My rule of thumb is that ?. is OK to use when

1) The reference is expected to occasionally be null in the course of normal operations

2) You legitimately don't care if the reference is unexpectedly null, as you wouldn't or couldn't fix it even if you knew about it

Otherwise it's better to discover and fix the NullReferenceException ASAP.

It's the null propagation operator.

Look, if you want to be pedantic it's the null conditional operator[1]. But it is widely called the "Elvis operator"[2].

[1] - https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/dn986595.aspx

[2] - https://www.google.com/#q=c%23+elvis+operator

Generally agreed, and out of curiosity I just looked through some fairly new code I have that's pretty heavy on C# 6, and only found a single instance of two null conditionals being used:

    Assert.That(r.Exception?.InnerException?.Message, Is.EqualTo("Exception result"));

Next closest thing that shows up a few times is coalescing to a default value:

    config?.OutputName ?? DefaultConfig.OutputName

Some other examples that show up a lot:

Invoke Action<> or Func<> that may be null or unassigned (this works for Events as well):

    actionHandler?.Invoke(value);

Extracting a value from a LINQ expression on a list of container objects (this one is actually from a unit test where it's explicitly only expecting one item):

    items.First()?.Data

Easy way to do a Coalesce on a specific property value in a collection:

    items.FirstOrDefault(item => item.Data != null)?.Data

    items.First()?.Data

I think this one doesn't do anything because .First() will throw on an empty collection.

The rest of your samples look fine to me though.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com