>I'm not a mathematician and was miserable at math in school, but I apply these habits in the business world every day. They help me cut through a lot of crap that comes from other people's sloppy/lazy thinking.
That's possible. The OP does not claim that the traits he listed apply if and only if you are a mathematician. It's certainly possible that you hone these skills without being mathematically inclined.
I do contest, however, that these habits apply to all "highly" rational people. I know plenty of people who are rational (or so are they deemed to be by their friends and colleagues) yet decidedly do not possess some of the listed habits, especially "scaling the ladder of abstraction" and "Being wrong often and admitting it".
On "being wrong often and admitting it," based on my experience, it's not that you become modest as a result of studying math. By studying math, you realize how prone your mind is to arriving at a faulty, unproven conclusion, and you learn to be more skeptical of your own thinking and become more at ease with being "wrong", allowing yourself to let your intellectual guard down.