Hacker News Reader

Comment by bad_user | Hacker News Reader

Yeah, but Google is not know for poor quality of its software. And as far as hardware quality goes ... there are mobile manufacturers that can deliver it (HTC, Motorola, Samsung, Nokia).

Surely Apple has control of the full stack, but it's not like history isn't repeating itself :-)

View on HN

Google isn't known for any quality of it's software. Google is known for their search engine. Yes, people on this site might tout the glories of Chrome, but to the average user, all they see is a search engine and email when they are on the web, and a slew of mobile devices that still aren't as clean and polished as the iPhone.

Anybody can polish a device that has intentionally-limited functionality.

Very true. And yet we still have so many feature rich yet experience poor devices, programs, and services out there. It's almost as if most people don't get the idea of quality over quantity...

Yes, and if there's a better recipe for success in consumer electronics, I can't begin to imagine what it might be.

One reason why Android is beginning to scare Apple is because the cell-phone carriers that aren't AT&T are marketing their Android-based phones against the iPhone with the good-old feature checklist. The iPhone gets one check "can receive phone calls", while the Android phone gets checks for things like "can play Pandora streams while you browse the web" or whatever.

People paying money for things like features.

Conventional wisdom has it that Android isn't so much scaring Apple as pissing off Jobs personally.

If Android is starting to scare Apple is because Google is doing ad revenue shares with carriers and device makers.

As for your example, first, it's requires too much qualification to really work on a feature matrix. Second, you really think that Apple can't/won't support app backgrounding or a more open app store if their current offering really starts hurting them?

Your assertion is debatable, but even accepting it: can just anyone figure out what functionality to leave out, and what functionality to polish?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com