Part of my work deals with medical patient safety but I study all sorts of safety including airlines, nuclear power, oil & gas drilling and refining, ....
There should be a mechanical fail-safe if the power cuts in this case.
Part of my work deals with medical patient safety but I study all sorts of safety including airlines, nuclear power, oil & gas drilling and refining, ....
There should be a mechanical fail-safe if the power cuts in this case.
In addition, the throttle control went through a pull cable device with an electromagnet. With the electromagnet on, a servomotor could operate the throttle. The emergency stop system would drop power on the electromagnet if the stall timer timed out, or on some other fault conditions. That forced the throttle to idle.
Then we had an Eaton VORAD radar. That data went into the main mapping system, along with LIDAR data, but it also was processed by a simple separate process that computed time to collision from range and range rate, and if it didn't compute a safe distance, or didn't reset the watchdogs, tripped the emergency stop system. If this happened, the LED sign on the back of our vehicle displayed "COLLISION IMMINENT".
This happened once during the Grand Challenge preliminaries. Several vehicles were in the starting gates side by side. We were ready to go, all systems running and armed, waiting for DARPA to release the hold signal they were sending by radio. The organizers decided to release the CMU vehicle first, and it came out of the starting gate and cut in front of our vehicle. The safety systems tripped and "COLLISION IMMINENT" appeared in the sign. After a few seconds, with the threat gone, the system reset and the sign went dark.
This was all fully automatic. There was also a remote engine kill system, required by DARPA.
We didn't win. But we didn't crash or hit anything. There were Grand Challenge entries that ran away, including, in 2004, one from CMU. Another one ran away because they filled their disk with logging info and this stalled the software. Steering and throttle froze, and the vehicle ran away until it hit something.
If you work on automatic driving, you have to prepare for trouble like this.
If your battery dies while the car is running (say, even, that something causes a physical disconnect between the batteries and the rest of the car — a wiring fault, or whatever). Ideally you would be able to pull to the side of the road while your vehicle coasts, braking as necessary.
If the system detects a power disconnect and instantly engages all brakes, does that help or harm? Additionally, since powered items like anti-lock brakes are now unavailable, how hard should the brakes be engaged? Fully? Slightly?
Slamming on the brakes in a failure scenario is not automatically the right answer. Odds are it's probably the wrong answer more often than not.
Are they unavailable? Electric cars have a main traction battery plus the conventional 12V battery that all cars have.
A motionless 2-ton rock in the middle of a busy interstate because of a power blip is a terrible idea. And again, how hard exactly should the system brake? Pick a value between 0% braking and 100% braking that brakes maximally without locking up the brakes.
A 2-ton brick spinning down a busy interstate because the brakes locked up is arguably even worse than a motionless one.
Additionally automatic transmissions have a transmission lock, but that won't work while the vehicle is in motion.
Some modern cars use electric systems for both, I'm not sure how that would work.
And the power braking system, being pneumatic IIRC, keeps working for a couple of hard stomps on the pedal even if the engine stops running and you lose 12V.
Pretty much the only thing you can expect to lose is the ABS. Even then, I understand that system has a failsafe such that it keeps the car from spinning in the event of malfunction and brake lockup. You can see this in ABS-related accidents as straight skidmarks. But I don't think that works when you've lost electric power.
Edit: actually, the recent Koenigsegg One:1 high speed crash (driver not hurt) during testing at the Nurburgring was an ABS sensor failure, you can see the hallmarks in photos. Koenigsegg also deserve big props for having been completely open about it.
And drift cars use a separate hydraulic brake attached to the rear disks.
Others (usually less expensive cars) have a set of drum brakes inside the disk brake that act as emergency brakes.
If you have rear drum brakes, it's the same as my first example. The emergency brake activates the normal braking system.