I've worked on many open hardware projects the past 6 years. Documentation is a huge problem with the majority of open hardware projects.
So what makes a good open hardware documentation?
My first measure for that is "is the documentation good enough so I can acquire all the materials for building it on the other side of the world".
My second measure is "is the documentation good enough for getting me started without wasting a lot of money on trial and error".
My third measure is "is the software or other important information still up to date".