Hacker News Reader

Comment by TeMPOraL | Hacker News Reader

> Who gives a shit?

I do. That's probably why I won't be running an effective business any time soon. Being nice and not fucking people over doesn't get you far in highly competitive markets.

I strongly second what 'nitrogen wrote[0]. This is very much about ethics.

> Is it ethical for a shop to advertise its products in the shop windows when the people running the shop know that there are higher quality products available in a competitors store?

In my opinion, no. Basically, if you know your product is shit, you are morally obliged to make it better or find something else to sell; lying to people to make them buy your stuff instead of something objectively better is fucking them over for your own gain.

Think about it the next time you find yourself on the receiving end of such businessmen.

[0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11759628

View on HN

That argument would lead you to the conclusion that if your peers are objectively better than you, then it's immoral for you to seek employment; you must improve yourself or choose a different industry. So do you think you are among the world's best in your area of expertise, or are you voluntarily unemployed? ;)

I do suffer from impostor syndrome sometimes :).

That said, most of my peers who are objectively better than me are already employed, and it's up to employers to select from the available pool of employees. My responsibility is to truthfully present my skills during interview.

If it is on the employer to make a value judgement on your skills, then isn't it also up to the window shopper to make a value judgement on the merchandise?

Well, yes - but in my original comment I didn't say that if you get half a feature behind your competitor, you should trash your merchandise and go do something else. I complained about people willingly making and selling shit, covering the deficiencies up with marketing.

In hiring analogy, it would be as if I couldn't code at all, but could talk my way through the interviews - and so instead of actually learning to code, I'd earn money by getting employed at companies and trying to extract as many paychecks and benefits as I can and then quitting before they figure out I'm a fraud.

Me investing my time to get a job through pure charisma, without bringing any merit to the table, is like selling products on pure marketing. Pretty dishonest, and also poisons the ecosystem for everyone.

Fortunately, hypocrisy is not a fallacy.

It is when other people do it.

> hypocrisy is not a fallacy

... but a warning sign that an argument is probably too broad, too absolute, too confidently stated, and has ten thousand exceptions that you didn't consider.

I completely agree and hope that more and more other engineers just say NO to aggressive advertising bullshit. It is not like one has no choice.

That's partially why I left Demand.

> I do. That's probably why I won't be running an effective business any time soon. Being nice and not fucking people over doesn't get you far in highly competitive markets.

> lying to people to make them buy your stuff instead of something objectively better is fucking them over for your own gain

Thanks, this needed to be said. I'm in the same position. I will probably never be able to run a business either because I hold these same views.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com