Comment by Bahamut | Hacker News Reader

Comment by Bahamut | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

To correct this a little, the proper way to catch with promises is .catch, not with a try-catch inside a .then - that is an antipattern. The promise examples as written are not proper promise usage.

I'm also in the boat of confused people of why is async-await requested by a good portion of the js community - wrapping the block within the function in a try-catch seems like a bad idea, a brute force mechanism. IMO this is language bloat, and does not really solve problems we have while introducing a more expensive vector for managing flow (try-catches).

One missed point about the .catch with promises is that it allows you to branch flow discretely - it is not a perfect solution for branching flow (it is awkward when branching due to more than just a binary outcome), but with await, one might end up writing repetitive code for certain flows where one expects common calls to be made downstream in async data fetching flows.

>To correct this a little, the proper way to catch with promises is .catch, not with a try-catch inside a .then - that is an antipattern.

Depends whether you can survive and continue from an exception inside the .then to the next step or not.

Promises catch exceptions and automatically reject: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Refe... . I've never seen a promise not do this - do you have an example where this is not the case?

As I wrote in depends whether you can survive and continue from an exception inside the .then to the next step or not -- not about how the promise would handle an exception, but whether you want it to handle it or you want to survive and handle it yourself.

e.g, naive example:

  .then(() => {
     var foo;
     try {
          foo = getFoo();
     } catch (err) {
          foo = 10; //some default value
     }
     return foo;
  }).then( (foo) =>

etc.

So you might not want to reject automatically inside then if getFoo raises, but recover and return a default value.

That example could be written:

    .then(getFoo)
    .catch(err => 10) //some default value
    .then( (foo) =>

cool, learned something new

Reply on news.ycombinator.com