Ask HN: Have ideas, not the skill (Yet) | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Have ideas, not the skill (Yet)

So I've been watching HN for a while now (2..3 months) and I'm just amazed at the amount of wisdom (good and bad) that floats around here. Big names.

I think it's pretty obvious that by having an account here I'm interested in startups and creating my own startups. I even have a few ideas in the back of my head (things I've attempted to do and only imagined).

The problem is that I simply don't have the skill or knowledge. I try to work on my projects but ultimately I realize that I won't be able to finish them on my own (yet).

So here's my question to Hacker News: Should I just ram through and keep hacking away on the projects or should I take my ideas to people who can do them/like them and sit back and watch?

Side question: If the latter, where should I present my ideas and how?

View on HN

It'll probably be most rewarding long-term to keep hacking away at them, especially if you've already taken the first step to begin.

If you're getting stuck at specific blocks, it's likely that you'll be able to find some resource to get you through it.

Right now the most difficult part is login stuff. <form> bull crap is bullcrap. :P

It depends on what you want to do with your ideas.

If you want to just give them away and see where it gets you, then go with that option.

If you want to pay somebody or share the development of a project with somebody, then find that person, and do that.

If you absolutely must get something done, then do it yourself.

That is how I got started in programming. Every programmer I spoke to about a project told me it couldn't be done. I didn't believe them, so I learned how to code, and built it myself.

It worked as a program, but failed as a business. Now I have the skills to not only build my own projects, but to help others.

That...doesn't answer my question(s) at all.

Should I just ram through and keep hacking away on the projects or should I take my ideas to people who can do them/like them and sit back and watch?

If the latter, where should I present my ideas and how?

You pretty much just restated my post in statement form.

You should do neither. If you present good ideas to people that can execute them when you can't, why wouldn't they just take them? You should just be patient, take a passive note for some additional months. Write out your ideas on paper. Write down your skills. Depending on your age, consider going to university or getting work to bring up your skills. Once you are able to execute a significant portion of the work, then and only then is it time to move forward.

Do it yourself, and learn the skills along the way.

- If your idea doesn't work, you will at least have new skills to show for your time.

- No-one will be as passionate or committed to your idea as you.

- There are a lot of ideas out there. The ones that succeed are the ones which are backed by passion and commitment.

If you enjoy programming, keep doing it and learn it.

If you don't, make friends with someone who does. And develop other skills along the way.

Once you've made friends/networked with some people, you can present your ideas to them and see if they're interested in working with you.

post script Most of my ideas usually involve having see X service and writing down a bullet list of ways to improve it/make it easier. IE UX/UI stuff.

Alternately: Spend some time wondering what you are "missing" and try to find a means to get that. For me, my health issues are a major obstacle. So getting well is my first priority. I have some secondary issues I am also working on, but I am clear that nothing will work as long as that personal issue remains a show-stopper.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com