Hacker News Reader

Comment by cft | Hacker News Reader

I like their new GEO sorted set with latitude and longitude. Can someone point me to a [reasonably priced] geocoding database to display nearest Town, Region (only where appropriate), Country (in English) based on latitude and longitude?

View on HN

It's a big deal to run (takes lots of hardware), but I really like nominatim. I've played with them all and it's the one I've settled on. Helps that I run it on a pair of OSM tile rendering and routing servers. Only downside to nominatim is the space requirement (~ 700gb), and the fact that it takes forever to build the database (24 - 36 hours on 256gb ram machines w/ SSDs....)

https://geocoder.readthedocs.io/#providers

We at Teleport have an open API for this as well, check if the following would be of use: http://developers.teleport.org/api/getting_started/#search_n...

I've used GeoNames (geonames.org) for a few projects.

I was turned off by their blurp that their US zip codes database contains only 21k zips out of 41.5k. Are they sufficiently complete for small towns?

The incomplete zips (for at least one database I've read about) come from corporate or industrial areas where not many people actually live.

Officially US zip codes are just collections of addresses, they don't necessarily correspond to areas.

I think most free datasets are probably just the areas that Census derived for TIGER (or at the very least, rely heavily on that data).

I'm using it for a photo app (I only need town/city level granularity), and it works well for my needs. Note that the dataset is based upon populated places though, so YMMV if you need to lookup somewhere in the middle of nowhere.

Here is a JavaScript library I wrote for it, along with some scripts for munging the GeoNames dataset:

https://github.com/lucaspiller/offline-geocoder/

If you need higher granularity, take a look at this OSM project:

https://github.com/twain47/Nominatim/

I can second GeoNames. Sometimes it's hard to beat free. We take a couple files from their dump[1] (primarily the city data) and import into a database. We can then geolocate a lat/long to the closest city.

1. http://download.geonames.org/export/dump/

An open data gazetteer https://whosonfirst.mapzen.com/

Wouldn’t it be possible to get this data from Openstreetmap?

More specifically, the OSM project Nominatim does Address->Lat,Lon

http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Nominatim

Reply on news.ycombinator.com