Hacker News Reader

Comment by mrweasel | Hacker News Reader

So, the plane will fly, it will just be hard to maintain and operate?

The best answer I can find is, "I don't know."

For years, the F-35 project has been calling ALIS absolutely critical. Now, they seem to be saying that the F-35 can fly without it and that ALIS only keeps the cost of ownership down.

I suspect that the real answer to that question is either classified or closely held amongst a core group.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operations_security

Inconvenient facts that don't help the F-35 agenda are national security secrets.

What a biased way to look at things.

"... Bogdan is saying ALIS is not really critical after all, insisting the F-35 can fly without it for 30 days."

So I guess we can wait and see what happens on the 31 day? SNAFU is all that comes to mind.

"Your trial period has expired. Please enter a valid product code."

I don't understand your question. The plane will fly if [_______________]...what, exactly?

EDIT: I am merely seeking clarification, not trying to evade answering.

Sorry, I meant the F-35 software that ensure that the plane will actually stays in the air is fine, with no real bugs left. The ALIS software, that helps ground crew, maintenance and mission planing, I assume, is still buggy, so you wouldn't want to use it in a war time scenario?

I'm not sure I'm making a ton of sense. It's just really interesting, I'm in Denmark and our government are about to pick which fighter plane will replace our old F-16s, and the F-35 is the favorite right now. This is despite experts saying it's a bad plane. What I understood from your comment is that it will fly just fine, but bugs in the ALIS software would make it harder to operate than anticipated.

The software that keeps the plane in the air is a totally separate thing from ALIS.

My understanding is ALIS was part of the 'pork' side of the F-35. It has relatively simple requirements and was simply used to extract as much money as possible from the government. That said, they have tried to make it essential as possible.

Sounds kind of like when EA made SimCity have a required online component and claimed it was required for doing some game calculations.

I'm not the parent, but I read it as "Will the F-35 fly without ALIS?".

Perhaps more: Is it still a fighter plane without it?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com