All Presidents Are Above Average

slate.com

9 pointsdwwoelfel2 comments

I don't doubt that history books for children often paint historical figures in more (or less) generous terms than reality would suggest, but this story is pretty thin on examples. Six quotes about 43 of the most studied men in history doesn't really say anything at all, especially when you consider that writers of adult history have their own unique biases.

It's not a hard-hitting exposé -- it's just supposed to be a little bit funny.

Sometimes the flaws aren't about details. It's the aura of holiness. Americans seem to think it's good that children have a sort of secular faith in their head of state. I'm not sure why.

I saw this book "Barack Obama: Son of Promise, Child of Hope" in my local bookstore once, which takes it way over the top. Unintentionally hilarious, or perhaps disturbing. Judge for yourself:

http://www.nikkigrimes.com/books/bkbarack.html

Reply on news.ycombinator.com