Total bullshit. If there was so little money to be made why is every exchange catering to high frequency traders? Why was the building across from the NYSE hollowed out to become a data center? Why are custom fiber optic cables being layed down specifically for it?
> If you're a retail trader, automated electronic traders make money off you by outbidding the markets to quote good prices to you for your dumb market orders, and then pocketing the spread --- in other words, they make money the same way market makers have always made money; they just make less of it at an instant, but at a far larger scale.
This seems to be typical of HFT apologists. They start to use terms that are defined in other terms that they've essentially made up, much like trying to get to the first principles of a religion. There are no 'market makers', there are people selling with a miminum price and people buying with a maximum price. They aren't outbidding the markets, they are front running by seeing an order, buying it, and then selling it to the original buyer. Everything else is there to obscure the truth. I've seen so many of these posts here and none of them has ever approached any sort of justification or validity.