Hacker News Reader

Comment by blasdel | Hacker News Reader

But can you pass classes around as objects after they're loaded? Do they have a value beyond their identifier?

Yep, you can pass them around, they do have values, in fact, they can have different values for the same type sometimes. This has been the case since well before Java even had reflection - having them around is fairly central to the Java dynamic loading and security model.

Yes, although Java's reflection is somewhat of a pain in the ass and limited in many ways. But you can take a Class object and call newInstance(), and it will invoke the class's no-arg constructor.

Moreover, reflection is less of a language feature and more of a very low-level library feature. In ObjC, one can write

    Class c = [SomeRandomClass class];
    id thingy = [[c alloc] init];

but Java won't let you do the equivalent:

    Class c = SomeRandomClass;
    Object x = new c;

  Class c = SomeRandomClass.class;
  Object x=c.newInstance();

Yes, but that's making use of runtime magic (the Class class) which isn't used outside metaprogramming.

When you define a class, say "Foo", instances of Foo are Foo objects. "Foo", itself, is an instance of a class named "Class" which is a direct descendent of the class "Object".

In Java's type system, classes are 'first class objects':

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-class_object

Reply on news.ycombinator.com