Tolkien is dreck. There I said it. It took my over a year to read Fellowship of the Ring because of how indescribably boring it is.
edit: I suppose I should add a note indicating that I'm aware of the absence of dragons in LOTR.
(I ask because you're my favorite writer on HN, and am curious as to what things influenced you)
Read the Great Gatsby last year, was shocked at how much I liked it. Will definitely give My Antonia a read.