Average faces are not more attractive. Their skin is just smoother
uni-regensburg.de
uni-regensburg.de
I have found this to be the most overwhelmingly common flaw with experiments reported by mainstream journalism, particularly those in the field of psychology.
Actually, the "average faces are more beautiful" claim hung up on something very specific (skin tone). I think it's small details that aren't controlled for that often invalidate the more abstract conclusion of psychology experiments.
I don't think you can make this observation from these two faces. There appear to be differences in terms of hair and eye color as well. Plus, the facial hair isn't as visible in the smoothed-out face. I may be being pedantic in pointing the second point out, but I still think it says that there's more involved here than just the skin.
Not to mention that the skin color appears to me to "dull" some of the sharper features of the face by making them less noticeable. I think a case can be made that skin can have an enhancing effect on an average face, but I don't think this is enough to write facial structure out altogether.
Ba-da-bum.