Since, as this article says, Tumblr's business model is depending on people using it, removing comments (in favor of pushing people toward reblogging) seems ill-advised.
Since, as this article says, Tumblr's business model is depending on people using it, removing comments (in favor of pushing people toward reblogging) seems ill-advised.
They've recently added a chat system. http://i.imgur.com/Aw8EEvh.png It's the smiley face in the middle. I don't know if it's default yet but I have it right now and it works fine. The only difference is that in a chat system comments aren't public, but if you're giving other people feedback this works fine. I think this is a good middle ground between the network effects they get with reblogging and just being able to give people feedback without spamming your followers.
It works ok, as you say, if you just want to say "Great job," but it's not the same use case.
My partner is also a user of Tumblr, and according to her much of the community are dissatisfied with the direction the company is heading. Actually, now that I think about it, the strategies outlined in this article are more likely to strangle both Tumblr and Yahoo than save either of them.
I'm almost tempted to start working on the-next-tumblr and see if it's possible to tempt all those users over to a platform better suited for their needs.
I think they want the reblog to be the primary form of engagement, but that's silly for a lot of things, because the entire original post shows up in the reblog by default. For a running community (just one example), that's pretty lousy: you don't want to clutter up your own blog just to say "That's really fast, congratulations! Keep it up!" to a dozen other people.