Hacker News Reader

Comment by chromatic | Hacker News Reader

I have no plans to use P6. It's probably years away from having the ecosystem sufficient to support what I personally want.

I have no plans to update the book to cover P6; I think it does what it needs to do as it is now.

View on HN

I'd bet Perl6 ecosystem will evolve very fast, I don't think you will need to wait several years

Anything that evolves fast also will have stability issues. Part of the draw of CPAN is the stability that comes from mature codebases.

I hope so. It's pretty bare at the moment, but it shouldn't take too much to get it to where, say, Go-lang was when people started to adopt it in earnest.

Won't Perl6 make the book redundant, I mean the whole reason we needed a Modern Perl book was because there was an old and crufty way of writing Perl5...but Perl6 ditched all that baggage so the only way to write Perl6 will be comparable to Perl5's "modern Perl" paradigm?

Modern Perl book was first released a few years before P6, which isn't even released yet. The companies that currently use Perl (at $work, even) are not going to switch to P6 any time soon, but can, and do benefit from the more recent best practices using Perl 5.

So I guess Perl's 5/6 break was also something of a bummer, huh?

I look at it in two ways.

First, Perl is installed on millions of machines by default, with full access to the CPAN--still one of the largest repositories of freely available libraries, with Perl's backwards compatibility and testing offering a lot of stability. If P6 comes out and succeeds, it'll still be quite a while before it can offer anything like that.

Second, I've given away electronic versions of the book for five years. It's not about the money or the job prospects for me. I figure the book's helped more people than I can count, so why not continue?

I figure the book's helped more people than I can count, so why not continue?

It's one of the finest programming books out there, about any language. And your work is very much appreciated. (We've never met, so I hope you don't mind me saying).

Reply on news.ycombinator.com