Hacker News Reader

Comment by brudgers | Hacker News Reader

Without sign on, how will your company validate that bug reports are generated by people who actually use the software? How will your company reliably attribute multiple bug reports to the same customer/site/version?

While I think outsourcing the bug reporting infrastructure is a good long term strategy, at the early stage of a company, talking directly to the customers on the phone may be more valuable, while outsourcing and/or "anonymizing" the identities of bug reporters increases the odds that a customer's bug report slips through the cracks.

There's a sense in which the value of bugs is high. They allow the business to connect with customers who care enough to report a bug rather than switching tools.

Good luck.

View on HN

Thank you for your remarks!

Have you experienced people reporting bugs that don't actually use the software? I think validating if a user is in fact a customer is not worth the effort.

In order to get a proper bug report with version number, we will just provide a simple template to fill in.

I understand that customers that care enough to report a bug are more likely to keep using the product. Wouldn't that be an argument for letting them post anonymous, because it makes it easier for them?

My gut tells me that the value in bug reports is as customer feedback and goes beyond the mere technical issue. For example, a dialog can unearth how the customer is using the tool, what other tools they are using, why they are using those tools, their level of experience, etc.

If nothing else, googling the domain of their email address may provide useful insights. Anonymous bug reports waste the user's intent to engage with the company. That's not to say there's not an argument for anonymous posting...on the internet there's an argument for everything. But anonymous bug reports push the needle toward less customer engagement...and maybe that's the underlying motivation because customer engagement is often harder than writing code and clearing bug reports.

My experience is that any box that anonymous users can type text into gets filled by bots. Authorization is a pretty much a solved problem in so far as it can be easily outsourced.

YMMV.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com