Hacker News Reader

Comment by glesica | Hacker News Reader

> This will probably be the last release. I won't be able to work on Shoebill going forward (by contractual obligation), so I wanted to race out one last release.

Really sad that companies put these kinds of restrictions on their employees...

View on HN

Well considering that the author went on to work at Apple, it sort of makes sense. I don't think he was explicitly told not to continue development, but it is likely that some sort of boilerplate part of his contract restricts him.

I don't think it makes any sense, and the fact that it's a boilerplate clause everyone gets makes it worse, not better.

Employers really need to stop trying to control what their employees do while off the clock.

The project depends on reverse-engineering proprietary (if archaic) Apple hardware/software. Do you think Microsoft would/should allow their employees to contribute to Wine? Or Nintendo employees working on open-source emulators?

Do you think I should allow you to drink tea? You'd probably say, "you can't allow or disallow that, you don't have that power." That's what I think Microsoft's position should be with regard to their employees' free time.

The funny thing is that in this case the Apple stuff involved is decades old by now!

I share your view. However, I can also see the employer's perspective in a scenario like the project for the company ships late but all employee's commits to the open source project the employee founded or participates are all timely.

I won't sign a contract the restricts what I do on my free time. Any place that does that is not a place for me.

I can see the employer's perspective as you describe it, as in "psychopaths might think this way," but I can't sympathize with it. I think this is something we need to regulate, just like we say employees can't tell you what god to worship or whether to have children.

s/employee/employer/

If you get a chance to edit that typo I'll delete this comment to reduce clutter. :-)

Thank you for pointing that out. I guess I'll delete mine after you delete yours. I hope it works that way.

Silly me, I didn't get back here in time to delete my comment! But we're probably long off the home page by now, so nobody cares much about a little clutter... :-)

Doing anything else is a form of slavery. Most people are somehow OK with it. That company basically owns you 0-24 and everything you produce for a hand-full of cash.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com