Ask HN: Why are there so few Show HN threads on homepage these days? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Why are there so few Show HN threads on homepage these days?

14 pointsnamikaze9 comments

Is this a trend that only I feel or do others find it too? There is none at the frontpage at this moment. Could it be that:

1. We are busy this time of year 2. The bar of approval at HN has raised higher 3. It is just you. Data shows that it has increased.

View on HN

Last July, "Show HN" got a dedicated page in the top menu:

https://news.ycombinator.com/show

There have been 33 new submissions in the past 24 hours.

Frankly, I'm not sure this answers poster's question. While Show HN submissions are visible and volume is high, quality isn't so much. Maybe this explains why Show HNs don't make it to the front (not worth voting up).

I'm suspecting folks aren't submitting to Show HN anymore. They'd rather someone else submit their project for them once it's out of MVP/beta and matures a bit more. It has a much better chance of being noticed and gaining traction then. I also noticed Show HN volume is much higher a day or two after YC-rejection emails are out.

Possibly the quality and traction bit. We've tried "Show HN's" but we've got better traction on BetaList. There's also ProductHunt around as well which may explain the drop in submissions.

Show HN shouldn't be a platform for advertising startups anyway. Too many submitters try to "show" landing pages which are nothing more than subscription forms, or services which have no published source code and require signing up to even see what it is and how it works, to get viral and get traction.

Being a place for people to show off their code and their (possibly incomplete, and not necessarily for profit) projects is what makes Show HN unique, on a forum otherwise biased towards startups and SV culture.

Of course, I recognize my personal opinion on the matter is not really relevant, but I don't think low volume is necessarily a bad thing.

I'm not against what you're saying w.r.t it being a place to show code and interesting not-for-profit projects, but we can't force Show HN to be that and only that. Forcing an open-source only culture on Show HN is no better than startups/SV forcing a for-profit culture on Show HN. I think we're better off with an open place that's balanced and healthy.

That's a fair point.

At the very least, though, I think users be able to do something with a Show HN submission besides just sign up for the beta. There should be content worth building a discussion around, even if it's just a mockup or preview of features.

HN agrees with you. The rules try to address that.

> Show HN is for something you've made that other people can play with.

> If your work isn't ready for people to try out yet, please don't put "Show HN" in the title.

> For example, blog posts, sign-up pages, and fundraisers can't be tried out, so they don't count as Show HNs.

https://news.ycombinator.com/showhn.html

What kind of traffic does the Show page get relative to the Front, New, and Ask pages?

4. Maybe there is just more traffic generally, so this slice of traffic is simply a smaller piece of the pie.

5. Some other explanation.

You never step in the same river twice.

People always bellyache about changes in a forum. They change. Time moves on. They weren't static creations to begin with. Plus, there are always random fluctuations that are just a blip and mean nothing in the grand scheme of things.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com