Basically, he thinks that news sites like Reddit/HN/etc are doomed to become tabloids, since their author's incentives are all screwed up.
The format of the post is a trick to both get on the front page of HN, and prove his point - that you're more interested in fighting and gossip than real information.
I created this account so I could come on here and correct these comments. I had to create a new account because I threw out my HN password about a week or two ago in hopes of staying out of these kinds of discussions. I don't know which specific incident on Reddit of deleting my comments and/or my account you're referring to, because I've done that many times, but it probably involved wasted time or inadequate explanation on my part and poor logic on the part of several other people.
it's basically a failure of discipline and priority-setting on my part. I'm getting better at it, though.