> BuiltWith sells my contact info in their list of "Shopify websites"
This right here is why you should always get domain privacy.
This right here is why you should always get domain privacy.
However, a domain needs to have a point of contact, in case of abuse or illegal activity. Domain privacy is a valid service, where the registrar serves as a proxy for you and hides your personal information from public view.
While you could argue that it should be included as a default service, the pricing of domains is almost entirely arbitrary anyway.